TRAINING TO FAILURE AND WORKOUT RECUPERATION
Q:Hello Milos,
Do you always believe in training to complete failure, and is high intensity training the only way to build muscle? Also, what are your thoughts about recuperation? For instance, how many days should you rest a muscle, after training it?
Regards, Turner
A:Hi Turner,
During the last 15 years or so, I have had the opportunity to talk, and actually workout with some of the world’s greatest bodybuilders, and strength coaches. Before I give you my opinion to your questions, I would like to point out that all of these great champs and coaches, had their own unique way of doing things. In other words, they all had their own favorite systems of building muscle size, and strength. As far as training to failure is concerned, many of them simply just do not believe in it! That’s right. You read it correctly. Some of the greatest physiques of all time do not; believe in training to total failure!
Take Bill Pearl for example, who is without doubt, one of the greatest physiques, of all time. When I asked Bill about this once, his reply was, “Why would you want to fail? To fail is to be negative, and why in the name of god would you ever want to fail at anything?”. Lee Haney, the current record holder of the most amount of Mr. Olympia titles, feels the same as Bill Pearl. I have lost count of the times that he has told me, “Training should stimulate, not annihilate!”
On the other hand great champions such as Mike Mentzer, Dorian Yates and Ernie Taylor, are pure products of training to failure, Heavy Duty style. They do as many reps as possible during a set, but when they reach positive muscular failure, (when the bar or dumbbells cannot be lifted again in proper form) they attempt to do even more reps, by using such advanced techniques as, forced reps, cheating reps, partial reps, and even rest pause. Their idea is to simply trash those muscle fibers, using the lowest, (low volume) amount of sets possible. In other words, instead of one gentle knock, which wouldn’t be enough, why keep on knocking when you can accomplish the exact same thing, with one carefully aimed blow??
However, while we are on this particular subject let me confuse you even more by revealing some of the amazing, and unbelievably hard training methods of John Brown, who was a champion bodybuilder and guru, during the 1980’s. (Editors note: John Brown was Shawn Ray’s and Vince Taylor’s trainer, and mentor. Also, Melvin Anthony just about owes his career to John Brown.)
Imagine this for a deltoid workout.
1. Without a warm-up, John would pick up two 30 pounders, and knock out 10 perfect reps, on the standing dumbbell side lateral raise, exercise.
2. Without any rest he would do another set of standing laterals for 10 reps, with 40 pound dumbbells.
3. Finally, he would grab a pair of fifties, and go right into another set of standing dumbbell laterals for 10 reps!
This constituted one cycle or triset. However, John was far from finished. Without rest, he would return to the 30 pounders, and this time do 12 reps, on the standing dumbbell lateral raise, followed immediately by another set of twelve, using the 40 pounders. Finally he would finish his second tri set, with the fifty pounders, again for 12 reps! As if this wasn’t enough, John would force himself through one more triset, this time doing 15 reps with the thirties, forties, and finally the fifties! Can you believe this? It does take some believing, doesn’t it? And, as if to rub salt in the wound, John once told me that back in his younger days, he pushed himself through another lateral raise triset, for 20 reps! Basically, what we are observing here, is that John Brown increased both the weight, and the reps, as he progressed through his workout. This is pure progressive resistance training, although it’s simply murder to get through. Just give it a try. The other interesting, or should I say amazing thing about John Brown, was the fact that he never believed in dieting. He believed that as long as he trained like an animal, then food, all kinds, could be eaten, in unlimited quantities. John and I competed together at the 1991 IFBB San Jose Pro Invitational, (which became my first Mr. Olympia qualification.) I actually saw him first hand, wolfing down, scrambled eggs with bacon and cheese, before the prejudging, followed by hamburger, French fries and cheesecake at lunch. Thank god I missed his evening meal!
I have mentioned several times in my previous “Words of Wisdom” columns, that I am a firm believer in training to muscular failure. Having said that, I would like to point out that I am a little more conservative in my approach, compared to others.
Let me explain. Instead of doing one all set to failure, of an exercise, I prefer to do three carefully planned sets. After important warm-ups, I pick an amount of weight that I think I can manage safely, for 6 – 8 reps, before failing. I perform this first working set, in a very slow tempo, (both eccentrically and concentrically) which is very much harder to do than a normal set. After a sufficient rest period, (because it is very important to allow enough recuperation time, between working sets,) I attempt my second set to failure, but this time I perform it at normal tempo, (slow eccentric, and explosive concentric reps). This really is an all out set to failure. My third and final set, is what I call my beyond failure set. This is where I call upon the help of my training partner, for two to three extra, forced reps. (Please note: I only use this system on two of my four exercises, for each body part.)
I must point out that I personally agree with the numerous published scientific articles, which have stated that in order to increase strength and muscle size, we must continually attempt to use maximal voluntary contractions. In other words the level of tension we impose upon our muscles, has to be sufficient to cause maximal motor unit activation. Muscle hypertrophy doesn’t just happen. We have to create physiological reasons for our body to “make bigger and stronger muscles”. For that we need an appropriate work load, or should I say “overload?” I would like to quote Mr. Olympia Ronnie Coleman, on this. “Everybody wants to get bigger, but nobody wants to lift heavy d**n weights!!” So overload, (a weight heavy enough to produce adequate stimulation) is essential, which is fine, but where do we draw the line? Should we always fail like Mentzer, Yates and Taylor? Or never fail like Pearl, Haney, and Michael Jackson?
You also asked if I always believed in training to complete failure. Well I will be a little diplomatic here, and say that we can periodically, push our body to complete failure, just like my third working set, or the entire work out of Dorian Yates and Ernie Taylor, plus other high intensity Heavy Duty followers. However, the human body is not a machine, and we can’t keep pounding away on it, because your body is a biological system, with many limitations. I hope you appreciate that I only periodically push myself to the limit, (two sets for each body part) but about every fifth or sixth workout, (for the same muscle group) I do not even attempt to push to complete failure. I back off for a week, (and sometimes two) by reducing both volume and intensity, allowing my body to heal. In my opinion it is absolutely NOT humanly possible to expect out bodies to handle this kind of punishment, day after day. Even high intensity proponents have to schedule low intensity periods… Even the obviously, infrequent but insanely intense workouts, of Dorian and Ernie dictate their need for longer recuperation times. They usually train a maximum of 3 – 4 times a weeks, because they have to.
Your other question regarding workout recuperation is like opening a can of worms! The two most extreme examples of zero workout recuperation, (yes you read it right) were Serge Nubret and Thierry Pastel. These two former great champs, used to train the same muscles every day, and don’t doubt me on this, because I’ve personally witnessed it with my own two eyes!
Ronnie Coleman, our current Mr. Olympia trains with both high volume, and high intensity. He currently works each muscle twice a week, which is unusual these days, because most top bodybuilders work a major body part only once.
Personally, I feel that workout recuperation is directly in correlation to your nutritional, and supplementation intake, plus adequate rest. Both these factors are of supreme importance when it comes to the question of “when is it time to work that muscle group again?” Even if you performed two identical training sessions, (with all parameters being equal) the true exact amount of recuperation time required, would not be 100% the same. However, if you pay more attention to your nutritional, and supplement support before, and after training, you will recover considerably faster, than if you did not. Also, if you improve your sleep and rest requirements, you will enhance your recovery even further. I have to be honest, and rather blunt about this, but I am constantly amazed, when I talk to young trainees on a daily basis, about their approach to workout recuperation etc. During my personal, and private consultations, I am often made aware that the average bodybuilder gives absolutely no, or very little consideration to what would be the ‘ideal’ recuperation period. Many inform me that they train and recuperate ‘instinctively’. In other words they train, and rest, when their body tells them to do so. While I certainly believe in ‘listening’ to the body, I highly doubt whether it’s possible for someone to effectively really know when it’s time to hit that same muscle group again. All I can say is try the experience on yourself. But, first and foremost, I would like to see you learn all you possibly can about nutrition, and supplementation. Once you have the perfect diet plan, (remember, those who fail to plan – plan to fail) combine it with a result producing training routine, and follow both religiously. Later, you can experiment with reducing your recuperation period between consecutive workouts, just to see what happens. Don’t exclude any possibilities, and be open minded. Find out for yourself if you’re a Pastel – Nubret six hours a day trainee or a Mentzer – Yates, one hour max advocate.
The truth is, you are actually probably somewhere in between, but don’t tell John Brown!
Till next time,
Milos